As the Miami Dolphins head into the 2025 NFL season, the pressure on head coach Mike McDaniel is higher than ever. After two seasons of early playoff exits, unfulfilled expectations, and rising locker room tension, it’s clear: McDaniel can no longer afford to be the “cool coach.” It’s time to drop the hammer.
McDaniel, known for his quirky personality and innovative offensive mind, has earned respect around the league for turning around Miami’s offense. But being a great play designer isn’t enough anymore. Leadership separates contenders from pretenders; right now, Miami is dangerously close to the latter. For the Dolphins to be legitimate Super Bowl contenders, McDaniel has to shift from being liked to being respected — and that starts with accountability.
Raheem Mostert, one of the team’s former leaders, recently appeared on The Dive Bar Podcast and gave some telling insight into the team’s mindset. While praising McDaniel’s growth, he subtly highlighted a leadership void, saying Mike still has things to learn. Mostert shared a personal lesson about not letting “something small and minute fester on to a Thanksgiving feast.” It’s a timely and almost ironic statement as it directly applies to what we continue to see from a supposed “captain” in Tyreek Hill.
Despite his undeniable talent, Hill continues to be a distraction on and off the field. Whether it’s legal drama, social media antics, or constantly craving attention, Hill’s behavior is a constant undercurrent threatening team cohesion. Just this week, he was again in the headlines for the wrong reasons, testing the patience of both fans and teammates. If McDaniel can’t rein in his star receiver, he risks the culture spiraling further out of control.
To turn the tide, McDaniel must lead in a way that feels authentic to who he is. He can’t suddenly become a sideline screamer or a coach who nitpicks players’ flaws—that would come off as disingenuous, and players would see right through it. What he can do is lean into his natural strength as a communicator and motivator while evolving into a coach who demands excellence, not just encourages it. That means having tough conversations, holding stars and role players to the same standard, and creating a culture where being a team-first competitor is in his words a “non-negotiable”.
The Dolphins have a talented roster and a window to win, but that window is closing fast. What’s missing is a unified, disciplined team culture. McDaniel has to set the tone — not with empty speeches or performative discipline but with genuine accountability. If McDaniel remains passive, the locker room will eat itself alive. And if he loses the locker room, the next thing he loses will be his job.
Anonymous NFL GM reveals what Dolphins Could Get in Return for Tyreek Hill
