Phins Phorward
Edition #21
Lowered Expectations
Let’s try to put those Phins Phorward! As a diehard and lifelong Miami Dolphins fan, I’ve learned to temper my expectations with a heavy dose of skepticism, especially lately, and the 2025 season is shaping up to be yet another exercise in futility. This team, perpetually stuck in the purgatory of mediocrity, seems destined to repeat the same old tired script.
There will be flashes of promise drowned out by injuries, poor decisions, and a maddening inability to close out games. I’m preparing myself for another long and frustrating season.
First, let’s talk about the elephant in the room, Tua. I want to root for him, I really do. He’s got a quick release, decent accuracy, and moments where he looks like the franchise quarterback we’ve been searching for since Marino. But let’s be real, his health is a ticking time bomb.
The man can’t stay healthy. I’m not holding my breath about getting a full season out of him. The guy’s made of glass, and every hit he takes feels like a countdown to another IR stint. I hold my breath anytime he gets flushed out of the pocket. Without Tua, this offense really suffers, because McDaniel built this offensive scheme to highlight Tua’s strengths and to try to hide his weaknesses.
If Tua inevitably goes down again, we’re looking at an even longer and depressing season.
Then there’s the offensive line, which might as well be a revolving door of turnstiles. The Dolphins’ front office, which doesn’t seem to value the incredible importance of a solid offensive front, keeps throwing random big and slow bodies at the problem.
This unit was a bottom-five pass-protecting group in 2024, and I see no reason to believe they’ll magically gel in 2025. Tua’s going to spend most of the season running for his life, assuming he’s even upright.
Also, I’m not expecting the run game to bail them out either. De’Von Achane is electric, but his small frame isn’t built for a full workload, and Jaylen Wright is unproven and starting the season injured. Off to a great start already.
The defense is suspect. Trading Jalen Ramsey was like waving a white flag. He was the heart of the secondary, and now we’re left with a patchwork of Cam Smith and Storm Duck, guys who should be on the practice squad, not our starting corners. Minkah Fitzpatrick’s return is a bright spot, but one All-Pro safety can’t mask the fact that this secondary got torched last year.
The pass rush definitely has potential with Zach Sieler and Chop Robinson, but Bradley Chubb and Jaelan Phillips are coming off injuries, and I’m not betting on both staying healthy. Anthony Weaver’s scheme might keep things respectable, but this isn’t a top 10 defense. It’s a liability waiting to be exposed by any competent quarterback.
Also, let’s not kid ourselves about the schedule. Six nationally televised games sound great until you realize they’re just opportunities for the Dolphins to embarrass themselves on a bigger stage. That Week 11 game in Madrid against the Commanders? I can already see us getting outcoached by Dan Quinn in front of an international audience.
The AFC East is no picnic, either. The Bills are going to win the division again as usual, and the Jets and Patriots have improved, whereas Miami has regressed. This Dolphins team has 7-10 written all over it, maybe 8-9 if we are lucky.
McDaniel and Grier are in the extremely hot seat, and frankly, they should be. McDaniel’s quirky play calling is getting old, and defenses have caught up, and his inability to adjust when Tua’s out or the line’s collapsing is glaring.
Grier’s track record of whiffing on draft picks, overpaying for middling free agents, and failing to fix the offensive line makes me wonder why he’s still employed. The Dolphins haven’t won a playoff game in 25 years, and I’m not holding my breath for 2025 to break that streak.
Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle are studs, but even they can’t carry this mess of a roster.
As a fan, I’m tired of the fake hype and the “this is our year” nonsense that fades by October.
The Dolphins are a house of cards, built on Tua’s fragile health and a defense that’s one injury away from collapse. I’ll watch every game like I always do, yell at my TV, and hope I’m wrong, but deep down, I know better. The 2025 season feels like another chapter in Miami’s endless saga of mediocrity. Wake me up when we’re relevant again!